It is often claimed that the gospels were published anonymously; that is to say, their autographs lacked formal titles bearing the familiar names which now identify them.
Yet this scholarly assertion may seem puzzling in light of the following facts:1
Almost all of our earliest Gospel manuscripts we have bear variations of the titles, ‘the Gospel according to X.’2 While these manuscripts date from the late second or early third century, we often take the earliest manuscripts to be a good reflection of what the authors originally wrote.
The traditional names attached to the Gospels are not contested, which we might have expected if they were originally anonymous. For example, we have no authors who tell us that actually Barnabas wrote the Gospel of Mark.
The gospel attributions to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John were accepted quickly across the Christian world, from Syria to Africa to France.
While the gospel authors never disclose their identities within their narratives, this is not at all unusual for ancient texts (including ancient biographies).3
Why, then, do the vast majority of Gospels scholars – from across the ideological spectrum – claim that the titles were not original? That the Gospels were, strictly-speaking, ‘anonymous?’ In this post, I unpack three reasons this view is held.


